How often does a mechanical watch really need a service?
The number you will find in most manuals is five years, sometimes ten for newer movements with modern lubricants. The watchmakers I have talked to are far less precise. Their answer is always the same: it depends on how the watch is worn and on what it is telling you.
What actually wears out
A movement is a set of steel pivots turning in jewel bearings, held together by a few drops of oil. Over the years those oils dry out, thicken or migrate away from where they belong. Once that happens, metal starts rubbing on metal and wear accelerates. The mainspring slowly loses strength, and the case gaskets that keep water out harden and crack.
None of this happens overnight, which is why a watch can run perfectly well for years past its “due date” — and also why waiting until it stops completely is the expensive option.
Signs worth paying attention to
- Amplitude on a full wind dropping below roughly 200° (see the timegrapher notes).
- The rate becomes erratic, or differs a lot between dial up and crown down.
- Power reserve noticeably shorter than the specification.
- The crown feels gritty or uneven while winding.
- Any condensation under the crystal — that one is urgent.
What I do
Once a year I put every watch on the timegrapher for a few minutes in two positions and write the numbers down. If they are stable compared to last year, I leave the watch alone. My oldest daily watch went eight years between services and the watchmaker found nothing alarming. A dress watch that mostly sat in a drawer needed attention after four: the oils had gummed up from lack of use.
If you swim with a watch, the movement is not the main concern — have the water resistance pressure-tested every year or two. It is quick, cheap and catches tired gaskets before they let water in.